Event 21 Sep. 2022
Kalidou Gadio Speaks at AIEN 2022 International Energy Summit
News 09 Sep. 2022
France’s Cour de Cassation Confirms Set Aside of EUR 452 Million Award Previously Issued Against Libya
Client Alert 20 Sep. 2022
Unexpected Events from Covid to Supply Chain Disruption: Implications for US Contract, Securities and Antitrust Law
Client Alert 29 Jun. 2022
Discovery, Jurisdiction and Service: Changes in U.S. Law and Implications for Japanese Companies
Client Alert 27 Sep. 2022
UNCITRAL Working Group III: An Update on Certain Key Issues in ISDS Reform
News 26 Sep. 2022
Curtis Italy Wins International Arbitration - Energy Award at Legal Community Litigation Awards 2022
News 23 Sep. 2022
Curtis Recognized by Latin Lawyer 250 (2023)
Event 22 Sep. 2022
Dori Yoldi Speaks to AbogadasMX on Practicing Law Abroad
News 27 Sep. 2022
Curtis Boosts Riyadh Office with New Corporate Partner Stuart Davies
News 16 Aug. 2022
Curtis Delivers More Firsts for the Government of Oman in its Defense Against U.S. Trade Measures
News 21 Sep. 2022
U.S. Department of State Presents Fulbright Specialist Award to Charles Howland for Project in Uzbekistan
Event 20 Sep. 2022
Susan Maples and Andrew Larkin Speak at the Biennial Conference of ASIL’s International Economic Law Interest Group
Client Alert 30 Aug. 2022
The EU Adopts the “Maintenance and Alignment” Sanctions Package
Client Alert 20 Jul. 2022
The EU Undertakes Fundamental Reform of the Legal Basis for Sanctions Enforcement
Client Alert 24 Jun. 2021
Update on Virtual Notarization (Executive Order 202.7) During the COVID-19 (Coronavirus) Pandemic (Updated: June 24, 2021) — U.S. Insight
Update on Virtual Witnessing (New York Executive Order 202.14) During The COVID-19 (Coronavirus) Pandemic (Updated: June 24, 2021) — U.S. Insight
Client Alert 21 Dec. 2020
The alert is available for download with the list of references and footnotes in English, Spanish and Italian.
What emerges from the special report on climate change published by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) (IPCC, 2018) is yet further confirmation of what we are all aware of: maintaining our current pace of waste and consumption is taking us perilously close to the point of no return to save planet Earth.
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) estimates that a total of US$6.9 trillion per year will be needed to achieve the objectives of the Paris Agreement on Climate Change by 2030 (OECD, 2018), which means that the solution to the climate challenge will, necessarily, pass through the economy; the financial world must develop new strategies to attract new investment.
Public and private capital must act together to finance the transition to a greener economy and to ensure the achievement of objectives in line with the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
The appetite for investing in sustainable finance is growing in both individuals and companies. The latest edition of the Eurosif Study on Sustainable Finance in Europe has shown a significant progression from 3% to over 30% for the period between 2013 and 2017 (Eurosif, 2018), while the latest Global Sustainable Investment Alliance reports that the volume of sustainable investments reached US$31 trillion in 2018 (GSIA, 2018).
The growing attention given to green issues has made banks adapt their financial offerings accordingly. The Vice-President of the European Investment Bank (EIB), Dario Scannapieco, announced in a recent interview (Capozzi, 2020) that by 2025 the EIB’s commitment will be to increase by 20% the annual funding that positively impacts on climate and the environment, and to stop funding energy projects that burn standard fossil fuels. For its part, Moody’s indicates that banks issued a record US$121.8 billion of green, social and sustainable bonds in 2019, which represents an increase of 41% on the previous year (Moody's, 2020), and Associazione Bancaria Italiana (ABI) recently announced that issuances in green and sustainable bonds by Italian banks have so far raised more than 2 billion euros, with a clear acceleration in the two-year period 2019-2020 (ABI, 2020).
The boom in the green bond market has also led to a significant growth in the issuance of this type of bond by financial institutions and companies, which amounted to around US$142 billion in 2019, with corporate issuances alone growing by 90% compared to the previous year (Stéphane Rüegg, 2020).
1. THE EU GREEN BOND STANDARD
The development of the EU Green Bond Standard (GBS) represents a crucial opportunity to increase the availability of capital necessary to fund the transition to a more sustainable economy and to achieve the international commitments undertaken by the European Union. However, while the market is growing, green bonds remain a fraction of the overall bond market (less of than 4% of the EU market as of 2019) (EC, 2020) mainly due to (a) the lack of agreement and clarity on what characterizes a “green” bond; (b) the often complex review procedures for green bonds; and (c) a lack of investable projects and assets (EC, 2020).
To address the issue, the European Commission’s High-Level Expert Group on Sustainable Finance (HLEG) recommended the creation of a uniform green bond standard within the EU, which was included as Action 2 of the 2018 Action Plan on Financing Sustainable Growth and assessed by the Technical Expert Group in their final proposal for a GBS in June 2019, recently updated in March 2020 (EC, 2020).
The GBS is a system of voluntary shared criteria for the issuance of green bonds, inspired by criteria and good practices currently widespread in the market, such as the Green Bond Principles – GBP (ICMA, 2018).
The “EU Green Bond” certification will be attributed to any type of bond or debt instrument, whether listed or unlisted, issued by a European or international operator which is GBS-compliant (Commission, 2019). This means that
In line with this, the European Commission is expected to publish a new Regulation on the GBS in the first quarter of 2021.
2. THE EUROPEAN ACTION PLAN
What does “sustainable” really mean in the context of finance? Under what conditions can an investment be considered sustainable? Which economic activities can be considered “green” and which criteria should be applied?
Since “green” can come in many shades, investors struggle to evaluate the truthfulness of the ethical and sustainability claims related to green investments, while issuers risk being accused of “greenwashing” (discussed in Curtis’ Client Alert 19 November 2020).
The European Union has tried to address the issue, and so far has launched several initiatives aimed at ensuring greater transparency, coherence and clarity with regard to the so-called “green economy.”
With the signing of the Paris Agreement on Climate Change in 2016, the Union committed itself to promoting a transition towards more sustainable economic models. In December of that year, the commitment was translated into concrete terms, with the establishment of the HLEG, which was tasked by the European Commission with formulating recommendations to build a sustainable finance framework.
On this basis, the European Commission published in March 2018 the Action Plan on Financing Sustainable Growth (EC, 2018), with the aim of providing a common approach to sustainability to ensure that financial operators have precise criteria defining, measuring and communicating the sustainable characteristics of their economic activities.
2.1 Harmonizing Transparency Rules for Financial Markets – Regulation (EU) 2019/2088
In December 2019, the European Commission published Regulation (EU) 2019/2088 on Sustainable Finance Disclosure (SFDR).
The SFDR establishes harmonized transparency rules for financial market participants and financial advisors; in particular: “requires financial market participants and financial advisors providing investment or insurance advice on insurance investment products (IBIPs), irrespective of the design of the financial products and the reference market, to publish written policies on the integration of sustainability risks and to ensure the transparency of such integration” (Recital 13 of Regulation (EU) 2019/2088).
This means that financial operators will be required to publish on their websites information about how they integrate sustainability risks into their investment decision-making processes. If these risks could affect the performance of the financial product, they will be required to communicate to what extent, in quantitative and qualitative terms, they could negatively affect sustainability factors.
In terms of information required, financial advisors will have to disclose how they have taken into account sustainability risks and environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors in the selection and choice of the financial product; and explain the negative effects on sustainability factors in their ongoing periodic reports (Abate & Travanini, 2020).
This standardized product certification should enable investors to better understand the level of sustainability of their investments.
Even though the SFDR will enter into force on 10 March 2021, professionals have already expressed concerns on the difficulty of collecting the data required by the legislation (such as water emissions, emissions of ozone-depleting substances, company policies on trafficking in human beings) and the costs this will entail (Tramonto, 2020).
2.2. A Taxonomy of Sustainable Finance – Regulation (EU) 2020/852
Among the priorities identified in the Action Plan is a new European “taxonomy” for sustainable finance, i.e., a shared system of definition and classification of sustainable economic activities (EC, 2018).
The Regulation (EU) 2020/852 of the European Parliament and the Council of 18 June 2020, on the establishment of a framework to facilitate sustainable investment, and the amending Regulation (EU) 2019/2088, set out criteria for determining whether specific economic activities contribute to the achievement of six environmental objectives, namely: climate change mitigation; adaptation to climate change; sustainable use and protection of water and marine resources; transition to a circular economy, referring to waste reduction and recycling as well; pollution prevention and control; protection of biodiversity and the health of eco-systems (the “Objectives”).
In order to be eco-compatible, economic activities shall: (i) substantially contribute to the achievement of at least one of the Objectives; (ii) not cause significant damage to any of the Objectives; (iii) be carried out in compliance with minimum social safeguards; and (iv) comply with technical criteria.
The Taxonomy Regulation provides for deferred application to 1 January 2022 and 1 January 2023, when the European Commission, supported by the Platform on Sustainable Finance, will adopt delegated acts to define the technical criteria for the selection of activities to be considered sustainable.
From that time on, asset managers and other professional investors will have to disclose the proportion of investments that are compatible with the finance taxonomy for each relevant financial product, including investment funds.
Timing is tight and many points remain to be clarified. The sustainability of investments must take into account social factors, and criteria will need to be developed to determine which activities are harmful to the environment (the so-called “brown” ones). Clarification is also needed on nuclear power, where the weight of the interests of the single Member States will be the tiebreaker (Tramonto, 2020).
2.3 Non-Financial Reporting (NFRD) – Directive 2014/95/EU
The strategy to strengthen the European framework for sustainable investment also includes the revision of Directive 2014/95/EU on Non-Financial Reporting. The NFRD provides for more stringent and standardized requirements on how companies communicate non-financial information and disclose ESG data.
Since 2018, large public-interest companies with more than 500 employees –including banks and insurance companies– have been required to add non-financial information on environmental, social and personnel issues, human rights, and active and passive corruption, into their annual financial statements (Giustiniani & Iussig, 2020).
In December 2019 the Commission announced the review of the NFRD and opened a public consultation, which ended in June 2020.
If the European Action Plan succeeds in ensuring a secure, transparent and effective regulatory framework, sustainable bonds could play a key role in the transition towards the achievement of the European environmental objectives.
Given the complexities of a subject still in the making, investors and financial operators will need to take a careful and analytical approach in managing their financially sustainable choices.
Attorney advertising. The material contained in this Client Alert is only a general review of the subjects covered and does not constitute legal advice. No legal or business decision should be based on its contents.
Daniela Della Rosa
Maria Hortensia de la Peña
+39 02 7623 2001
+54 11 5196 8300